Change of Defensive Emphasis

Posted in Liverpool FC, Rafael Benitez, Tactics, Uncategorized on August 29, 2010 by Rob McDonald

One of the paradigms that was the hallmark in the Rafael Benitez era at Liverpool, arguably cribbed from Arrigo Sacchi whose Milan side placed an emphasis on their only ever being 25m from back to front at any given point in time, was the ability for the team unit to shift in unison. This meant that when the team attacked the defence pushed up to compress the open space available for the opposition to play in should they win the ball back, and also placed more pressure upon the opposition team when going forward. This was the main tactical point that allowed Liverpool to maintain dominance in territory and possession (or certainly during their good days) and essentially compress teams into submission.

There was a trade-off, however, to this method of play. And that was that Liverpool often had to rely on a spark of brilliance when they couldn’t pass their way around a team, usually Fernando Torres, Steven Gerrard or Yossi Benayoun. A lack of dexterity and agility in going forward as this way of play required a destroyer (or two) to play in the defensive midfield position to quater back the play, as it were. Obviously, the pinnacle of this was Xabi Alonso’s best season in red shirt in 2008/2009 when he played the metronome alongside Javier Mascherano and Liverpool essentially bossed opponents out of the game by not surrendering them any territory. This meant though that when teams purposefully came to Anfield to stifle Liverpool and put ten men in front of them they often lacked the imagination or dexterity to get through them, or relied on a bundling last minute goal as the pressure increased. This meant that Liverpool weren’t often pretty to watch, but it was rare that any team dominated them (the most obvious examples being Milan in the 2005 final – and that was when Benitez was implementing his idyll – and the Champtions League quater final against Chelsea at Anfield in 2009).

Roy Hodgson is obviously still in his infancy as a Liverpool manager, but in the early games the main problem has been the inability to retain posession or attain any semblance of dominance (needing a solid defensive display against Arsenal, aided by being down to ten men, leaving it the only option available and then being completely outplayed by Manchester City). The main difference in the way Liverpool have played thus far has been that the defence has dropped a lot deeper (maybe due to fears of the lack of pace between Carragher and Skrtel) and this, coupled,with a change in formation with Kuyt and Jovanovic dropping deeper and a more orthodox central midfield pairing has meant that the slow patient build up play and compression of space has lead to Liverpool looking completely at sea and not being able to get a foot hold.

The change in the mode of play can be seen here:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/chalkboards/nuf878f4883y2527Z5h6

Although Martin Skrtel is playing on the different side of the pitch, you can see that a distinct amount of his passes come from deeper. This coupled with the fact he doesn’t have a midfielder closer to him to distribute to means that Liverpool have struggled to form any patterns of play. Indeed, the main pattern has been Gerrard getting the ball and trying to play a killer ball from deep as there aren’t any options with Kuyt and Jovanovic deeper rather than higher up the pitch.

The signing of Raul Meireles suggests that Hodgson will intend to employ the 4-2-3-1 as favoured by Benitez (with him being coupled with Lucas or Poulsen who provide a more defensive outlet), but if the insistance is of a deep defensive line then it’s going to take a very taleneted distributor to take the reigns deep in the park to help attain more dominance in possession. The early suggestions are of this and the imminent signing of Konchesky also shows that Hodgson wants two attacking full backs, perhaps Cole will be placed to the left of Gerrard and Konchesky will be the oulet to provide width on the left.

However Hodgson decides to get Liverpool to play, something needs to change fast or Liverpool will risk being in a dangerous place come Christmas.

Liverpool V Arsenal

Posted in Liverpool FC, Tactics on August 17, 2010 by Rob McDonald

As the football season has finally gotten under way again and the excitement in myself has died down a little, I’m not entirely sure what to make of the first performance of the season. The most immediate concern is the inability to retain the ball, with Gerrard showing his greatest strength and greatest weakness in a single performance: great passing range, but his want of the ‘Hollywood ball’ constantly isn’t good for building patterns of play, especially when you have a young and inexperienced forward upfront who, although overall very good, let his youthful exuberance take hold on too many occasions and kept finding himself offside.

It is possible that Hodgson told him to play this role as Arsenal were playing such a high line and with a new defensive partnership, it seemed an easy target to try and get in behind them, but it surrendered too much territory and possession in the first half. In this sense it was almost the best thing that could happen that Joe Cole got sent off, it allowed us to play a practical game with two banks of four and letting Arsenal trying to break Liverpool down, which was obviously greatly helped by N’Gog’s goal in the first minute of the second half.

This inability to create patterns in play was a concern though, and beyond that it seemed that Hodgson wanted the Liverpool forward line to play quite a fluid game, with Kuyt roaming forward to join N’Gog on several occasions and Jovanovic cutting inside to provide another outlet. Obviously, it’s far too early to say this is a bad tactical move, but it didn’t seem to click in the game and it showed. Agger was never going to provide much of an attacking outlet from left back and although Glen Johnson made up for this with his attacking surges on the right, which obviously would allow Kuyt to cut infield and provide another spearhead to the attacking play, there still seemed to be a slight incomprehension when Liverpool when forward, with not many options on going forward or players being too easily stifled out of possession.

The main point people picked up on in the first half was the pseudo-battle between Samir Nasri and Joe Cole, saying that Nasri was more imperative to Arsenal’s attacking play and played a larger role in the first half, with Joe Cole being largely anonymous for Liverpool. But to say this is Joe Cole’s fault is a bit rash as he was left very isolated and struggled to get on the ball with Liverpool not being able to build up any possession in the Arsenal territory, whereas Arsenal played much higher up the field and pressed Liverpool, allowing Nasri an easier job as the focal point of their attack.

All in all, the main thing to take from the game was something that was lacking so severely in Benitez’s last season, and that was Liverpool keeping their heads up and working hard to get a result. Indeed, it was only an unfortunate error by a rusty Pepe Reina that gave Arsenal their late equaliser, with them not creating much of anything throughout the entirety of the game. It was a solid start, but I can’t shake the feeling that a full strength Arsenal would have caused a lot more problems for Liverpool and that it was their lack of attacking dexterity going forward and incisive play (aside from a good move from Rosicky which forced a good save from Reina) that allowed Liverpool to prosper so much.

Rafael Benitez’s Proposed Tactical Shift

Posted in Liverpool FC, Rafael Benitez, Tactics on July 29, 2010 by Rob McDonald

Liverpool fans, with the gift of hindsight, can now look back upon the Summer of 2009 as the summer Rafael Benitez lost the plot. If not the plot, he certainly lost a lot of the devotion and belief that he had built in his years previous. A lot of pundits have pinned both the sale of Alvaro Arbeloa and Xabi Alonso on to him, and although many people argue this is true, there are two sides to every story. Of course none of what happened will be made public, but no one has ever considered that Xabi Alonso played the role of ‘poor me’ very well and in the process delivered himself into the greedy paws of Real Madrid.

I’ve heard countless people say that Benitez sold Arbeloa for a few million and brought Glen Johnson for £18m and that this was a bad mistake, but they don’t consider the fact that Arbeloa was a Madrid lad and wanted desperately to go back to his home town club, which is very understandable and only had one year of his contract left. When you consider that the reputed Glen Johnson figure doesn’t encapsulate money supposedly owed by Portsmouth to LFC for Peter Crouch and that in Glen Johnson LFC captured one of the most dexterous and attacking full backs that England has ever produced, although there are still question marks about his defensive ability. But Benitez only sees attributes and what a player can add to a side, that’s how we ended up with Jermaine Pennant. In pre-season Glen Johnson lined up at left back in the majority of the friendlies that Liverpool played, and this was specifically designed to try and build on his defensive frailties and I don’t think it’s unfair to say that over the course of the season Johnson did improve the defensive side of his game.

It was in 2008 that Benitez first tried to shift Xabi Alonso, with a reported fee of £14m being touted in a possible move to Juventus, and this is supposedly the catalyst for Alonso’s unhappiness and request to be transferred a year later. A lot of revisionism has been applied to Xabi Alonso’s history at Liverpool Football Club, and the main part of his history that has been largely ignored is how poor he was in the 2007/2008 season, and how he had faded from his good start at Liverpool. Teams had realised that if you shut down Alonso then you shut down Liverpool and he was targeted and marked out of games and faded as a force. This was the primary reason that Benitez felt that a more agile player had to be brought in, someone who could play the Alonso role more dynamically, and he believed the answer to that problem was Gareth Barry.

As is well known Gareth Barry didn’t sign for Liverpool and Xabi Alonso didn’t leave the club, instead he went on to be the most valuable performer in Liverpool’s best performance in the league in nearly two decades. Liverpool played effectively with Xabi Alonso playing the lynch-pin of Liverpool’s attack and providing a metronomic background to their attack, although this proved to also be Liverpool’s greatest weakness with a lack of dexterity in attack against teams that came to Anfield sheerly to defend. Rafael Benitez’s Liverpool hit their prime during this season but because of the, supposed, lamentations of Xabi Alonso after nearly being forced out of the club he forced through his transfer to Real Madrid the Summer afterwards. In hindsight it can be said that had Liverpool’s core quartet of Javier Mascherano, Xabi Alonso, Steven Gerrard and Fernando Torres had started more than four games together through out the season, as well as Steven Gerrard not getting dragged into a court appearance, that Liverpool would have won the title.

In the summer of 2009 there were three major losses to the Liverpool squad. The aforementioned Xabi Alonso, who was replaced with a midfielder who represented a massive gamble due to his injury record but would eventually provide Liverpool with the more agile central midfield that Benitez had sought the summer previous with Gareth Barry, Alvaro Arbeloa and Sami Hyypia. Arbeloa was replaced with an English player, who with new rules to squad registration was important, and who also provided Liverpool with more impetus going forward. Hyypia was an experienced and respected head in the dressing room and his loss was one of the less spoken about in the years following but is possibly more pivotal. Losing someone who can maintain calm within the dressing room and provide not only defensive solidity but also good footballing ability when called upon, was a major problem. And due to the financial problems at the club the player to replace him wasn’t anywhere near as good a player as Sami Hyypia, with no disrespect to Soitiris Kyriagkos, who was primarily important due to the fact that he was an institution at the club in the new era. But he couldn’t be guaranteed first team football and left to get it, which is something neither party could begrudge.

The transition was meant to be made to a leaner more agile side that would be able to break down sides better and remain solid defensively. Unfortunately it was something that had nothing to do with this change in emphasis that proved such a stumbling block, instead it was Benitez’s belief in zonal marking that proved to be one of his primary downfalls. That is not to say there is anything wrong with the system within itself, it had provided a sound defensive backbone to the side the four years previous, but with the loss of Alonso and Arbeloa’s aerial presence – with Lucas having to replace him for long periods of the season, and Glen Johnson having to adapt to a new defensive structure – coupled with the necessity of playing Emilano Insua more due to Fabio Aurelio’s injuries, who had always been very quietly efficient aerially, meant that Liverpool became a lot weaker at defending set pieces. This compromised the defences faith within the system and a lot of mistakes, particularly by Jamie Carragher, lead to a lot of goals conceded from situations that perhaps wouldn’t have come about in the years before.

A lack of authority, with Mascherano, Carragher and Gerrard all starting the season in awful form, was also one of the reasons for Liverpool’s poor start to the season that so deflated the squad – coupled with a lack of investment beyond squad replacements – lead to such a poor season for them. The lack of depth within the squad is the reason that everybody points to, but it is not the only reason. Just too much went wrong in one season for Benitez’s reign to survive, and we will never know what a fully realised shift in tactical emphasis would have yielded for the team.

Lucas Leiva

Posted in Liverpool FC, Lucas, Tactics on July 26, 2010 by Rob McDonald

Now the dust has settled on World Cup 2010 and South Africa has been swiftly vacated, the dissections of the tournament have begun in earnest. But the player who has dominated the majority of my thoughts is a player who wasn’t even there.

One of the least celebrated amongst fans, but applauded by critics for his performance, was Sergio Busquets. The lanky Catalonian was the pivot on which Spain based their attack and defence. Playing the un-glamorous role quietly and effectively is a very difficult job to do and one Busquets absolutely dominated throughout the tournament.

With Spain’s tactics entirely hinged upon being dominant positionally and with possession, Busquets effectively played a role which required concentration beyond anything, not entirely dissimilar to that of a goalkeeper for a dominant side, and although his job was to intercept attacks and play the simple ball, it was his tactical nuances that allowed Spain to press so high up the pitch and know they had a stability in the centre of the park with Busquets there.

Tactically Busquets played the biggest role in the fluid system that Spain (and his club side Barcelona) used, dropping back into centre back with Pique and Puyol pushing either side of him and allowing Capdevila and Sergio Ramos to push on down the flanks to give the side the width that it lacked, but remain secure at the back. It also accounted for the occasional sojourn that Puyol and Pique are liable to make.

So, why does this make me think of Lucas Leiva? Well the diminutive Brazilian is a player who would be much more heralded for his ability in a more successful team (a la Busquets) but instead he is derided as a flop at a club where he was one of the top 5 players last season and has grown in influence and ability season upon season. But because he doesn’t do crashing tackles (Mascherano) or score many goals (Gerrard) or play killer balls (Xabi Alonso) he is the rotten apple who is the reason Liverpool haven’t been successful in the years since he started to become a first team player. This viewpoint is  so commonplace in the English press that no one batted an eyelid when the reputed bid from Palermo was only £3m this Summer. But had he played at a club like Barcelona and played the necessary role that he can play so well, he’d be valued closer to £10-15m.

Last season it was his tactical astuteness that complimented Javier Mascherano’s blood and thunder approach, and even though the club stuttered all through the season, Lucas shone. Although he was the player that everybody felt was expendable he was the one who managed to counterbalance Mascherano’s brashness, and his bad form for stretches of the season, but because he didn’t step into the role vacated by Xabi Alonso on his exit to Real Madrid he was considered as un-necessary. But when you consider the inexperience of Emiliano Insua at left back and Glen Johnson’s more gung-ho approach than Alvaro Arbeloa the necessity for a player like Lucas who can anchor the midfield and nullify opponents becomes more apparent.

The more he grows in confidence the more he grows into his position, he has shown the mental toughness to get through much derision, even from his own fans, that is a necessity for him to play his role. He improved his tackling ten fold and even showed more going forward showing that he might actually be Brazilian after all. Infact, towards the latter part of the season he showed that if he is allowed more free reign to move forward he has shown good timing in arriving in the box but completely lacks confidence in front of goal, but he has the tactical nous to get into good positions and although I’d imagine he’ll play the more defensive role of the two central midfielders I’d expect Hodgson to employ he might be a surprising package should he be allowed to make the occasional run forward.

Indeed, I expect that should Alberto Aquilani and Lucas Leiva be the main central midfield partnership for Liverpool next season it’ll help provide them with a more dexterous attack going forward with both of them alternating getting forward -albeit I imagine Lucas to play the more restrained role out of the two-, and although Hodgson will prioritise shape and structure, I can’t imagine him restricting his two central midfielders entirely to defensive roles.

Out of a fair proportion of the squad, I can’t see a more Roy Hodgson player than Lucas, who has built his game upon tactical muscle rather than physicality or dynamism, and I am can see him excelling and finally place himself in the position he deserves to be, a respected first team regular. He could even prove to be the lynch pin in a side that can build upon how reliable he can be. Although he doesn’t have the physical strength or the height to drop into a very defensive position like Busquets does to create a dynamic defence, he certainly has the ability to play to a similar level as he and be a fundamental part of the Liverpool team. Especially if Aquilani plays a role where he supplements whoever starts in the attacking roles more, which will necessitate a player who can play the holding midfield role that can nullify counter-attacks.

Introduction

Posted in Uncategorized on July 26, 2010 by Rob McDonald

Hello, my name is Robert McDonald and I’m twenty-one years old and read too many Jonathan Wilson articles and watch too many football matches. This has caused me to think I have an opinion worth spouting on the internet about football, thus I have created this great pedestal for me to speak from. I’m not going to pretend that I’m always right, and there are times when my facts will be wrong. I am welcoming to debate and correction, this is as much for me to learn and to debate as to speak from. I am an avid Liverpool fan and although I primarily watch the English Premier League and La Liga, I know bits and pieces from other leagues and will hopefully blog about them as I go. So, yeah, welcome to my brain.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free